What Is a Reasonable Result for a Collaborative Study?

 What Is a Reasonable Result for a Collaborative Study?

Collaborative testing provides a means for estimating the variability (or repro- ducibility) among analysts in different labs. If the variability is significant, we can determine that portion due to random errors traceable to the method (σrand) and that due to systematic differences between the analysts (σsys). In the previous two sections we saw how a two-sample collaborative test, or an analysis of variance can be used to estimate σrand and σsys (or σ2rand and σ2sys). We have not considered, however, what is a reasonable value for a method’sreproducibility.

An analysis of nearly 10,000 collaborative studies suggests that a reasonable es- timate for a method’s reproducibility is

R = 2(1–0.5 log C)              …………….14.26

where R is the percent relative standard deviation for the results included in the col- laborative study, and C is the fractional amount of analyte in the sample on a weight-to-weight basis. For example, when the sample used in a collaborative study is 1 ppm (μg/g) in analyte, C has a value of 10–6. The estimated percent rela- tive standard deviation, therefore, is

R = 2[1–0.5 log(10–6)] = 16%

Equation 14.26 appears to be independent of the type of analyte, the type of matrix, and the method of analysis.


Of course, equation 14.26 only provides an estimate of the variability in results submitted by those participating in a collaborative study. A relative standard devia- tion that is within one-half to twice the estimated value suggests that the method performs acceptably when used by analysts in different laboratories. The percent relative standard deviation for a single analyst should be one-half to two-thirds that for the variability between analysts.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Where to Sample the Target Population

Image
  Where to Sample the Target Population Sampling   errors   occur   when   a   sample’s   composition   is   not   identical   to   that   of   the population   from   which   it   is   drawn.   When   the   material   being   sampled   is   homoge- neous,   individual   samples   can   be   taken   without   regard   to   possible   sampling   errors. Unfortunately,   in   most   situations   the   target   population   is   heterogeneous   in   either time   or   space.   As   a   result   of   settling,   for   example,   medications   available   as   oral   sus- pensions   may   have   a   higher   concentration   of   their   active   in...
Read more

Basic Components of Spectroscopic Instrumentation

Image
  Basic Components of Spectroscopic Instrumentation The   instruments   used   in   spectroscopy   consist   of   several   common   components, including   a   source   of   energy   that   can   be   input   to   the   sample,   a   means   for   isolat- ing   a   narrow   range   of   wavelengths,   a   detector   for   measuring   the   signal,   and   a   sig- nal   processor   to   display   the   signal   in   a   form   convenient   for   the   analyst.   In   this section   we   introduce   the   basic   components   used   to   construct   spectroscopic   in  struments. Sources of Energy All   forms   of   spectroscopy   require   a ...
Read more

Quantitative Applications - Coulometric Methods of Analysis

Image
  Quantitative Applications Coulometry   may   be   used   for   the   quantitative   analysis   of   both   inorganic   and   organic compounds. Examples of controlled-potential and controlled-current   coulometric methods   are   discussed   in   the   following   sections. Controlled-Potential Coulometry  The majority of controlled-potential coulometric analyses   involve   the   determination   of   inorganic   cations   and   anions,   including   trace metals   and   halides.   Table   11.8   provides   a   summary   of   several   of   these   methods. The ability to control selectivity by carefully selecting the working electrode’s potential,   makes   controlled-potential   coulometry   particularly   useful   for   the   analy...
Read more